When it comes to roofing, homeowners are often faced with a tough decision: stick with traditional asphalt shingles or invest in the increasingly popular option of metal roofing. While both have their place, the long-term data paints a clear picture.
At Everflow, we believe in helping you make the smartest investment for your home. Whether you are building a new home or considering a roof replacement, this guide breaks down the real differences between metal and asphalt shingles in terms of durability, cost, and performance in our harsh Canadian climate.
Durability: The Lifespan Factor
This is the biggest differentiator. When analyzing long-term value, metal is the clear winner.
- Traditional Shingles: Asphalt shingles typically last 15 to 20 years. In Saskatchewan, where UV rays and freeze-thaw cycles are intense, shingles can become brittle, curl, or lose their protective granules prematurely.
- Metal Roofing: Metal roofs are known for exceptional durability, often lasting 40 to 60 years—two to three times longer than traditional roofs. They are resistant to cracking, warping, and rotting.
The Verdict: You might buy two or three asphalt roofs in the time you own one metal roof. This longevity means fewer replacements and less hassle over the lifetime of your home.
Weather Resistance: Snow, Ice, and Hail
Living in the prairies means your roof must withstand everything nature throws at it. Here is how they compare:
Snow Shedding
If you live in an area with heavy snowfall, metal roofing performs exceptionally well. Its smooth surface allows snow and ice to slide off easily, preventing the heavy buildup that causes structural stress and ice dams. Shingles, with their rough texture, hold onto snow, which can lead to moisture backing up under the roofline.
Wind and Hail
Metal roofs are engineered to withstand high winds and are highly resistant to hail damage. Unlike asphalt shingles that can be torn off in a storm or bruised by hail (leading to leaks later), high-quality metal panels stay secure and intact.
Energy Efficiency: Keeping Costs Down
In today’s world, efficiency is everything. Metal roofing has a distinct advantage in thermal performance.
Summer Cooling:
Metal reflects solar radiant heat rather than absorbing it. This can keep your attic and upper floors significantly cooler in the summer months, reducing the load on your air conditioning and lowering your utility bills.
Winter Performance:
Properly insulated metal roofs help maintain consistent indoor temperatures. Unlike shingles that absorb heat and then radiate it into the attic, metal creates a more stable thermal envelope.
Maintenance Requirements
How much time do you want to spend worrying about your roof?
- Traditional Roofs: Require regular inspections. You need to watch for missing shingles after wind storms, moss growth in shaded areas, and granule loss in your eavestroughs.
- Metal Roofs: Essentially maintenance-free. They do not rot, support moss growth, or attract insects. Occasional cleaning to remove debris from valleys is usually all that is required.
The Cost Reality: Upfront vs. Lifetime
We believe in being transparent about pricing. This is usually the deciding factor for most homeowners.
Initial Investment
- Traditional Shingles: The most affordable option upfront. This makes them the standard choice for homeowners working with a tighter budget or looking for a quick fix before selling.
- Metal Roofing: Higher initial cost. The materials are premium, and the installation requires specialized labor.
Long-Term Value
While the upfront check is larger for metal, the cost of ownership is lower. When you factor in the 50-year lifespan, zero maintenance costs, and energy savings, metal is often the cheaper option over time.
Need help with the budget? Check out our financing options to see how we can make a premium roof affordable.
Aesthetics and Curb Appeal
Metal roofing has come a long way from the “barn look.” Today, it offers a sleek, modern aesthetic that stands out.
- Variety: Available in steel, aluminum, and copper, with profiles that can even mimic slate or wood shakes.
- Resale Value: A metal roof is a major selling point. Potential buyers know they won’t have to replace the roof for decades, which can increase your home’s market value.
Why Choose Everflow for Your Roofing Project?
Whether you decide on the classic look of asphalt or the modern durability of metal, installation quality is what matters most.
- Expert Installation: Metal roofing is not a DIY job. It requires precise cutting and fastening to allow for thermal expansion. Our team is trained specifically in these systems.
- Warranty Protection: We stand behind our work. We offer comprehensive warranty protection to give you peace of mind.
- Honest Advice: We won’t push you into a product you don’t need. We assess your home, your budget, and your goals to recommend the right solution.
Conclusion
Metal roofing is a smart, sustainable, and durable choice for Saskatchewan homes. It offers superior protection against fire, wind, and snow while lowering your energy bills.
Ready to Compare?
If you are still on the fence, let us give you a side-by-side quote. We can show you exactly what a shingle roof vs. a metal roof would cost for your specific home. Contact Everflow today or request a free estimate to get started.
